The crisis of confidence in legislation

Prof. Maria De Benedetto; Prof. Nicola Lupo; Prof. Nicoletta Rangone

doi:10.5771/9783748907244

Summary

Die Beiträge des Sammelbandes beschäftigen sich mit der Frage, wie das Vertrauen in den Staat und seine Gesetzgebung wiederhergestellt werden kann.

Search publication

Bibliographic data

Copyright year: 2020
ISBN-Print: 978-3-8487-6645-1
ISBN-Online: 978-3-7489-0724-4
Publisher: Nomos, Baden-Baden
Series: International Association of Legislation (IAL) / Deutsche Gesellschaft für Gesetzgebung (DGG)
Volume: 19
Language: English
Pages: 365
Product type: Edited Book

Titelei/Inhaltsverzeichnis No access Pages 1 - 14
Maria De Benedetto
1. 1. Introduction No access Maria De Benedetto
2. Maria De Benedetto
  1. 2.1 Different Words, Different Meanings? No access Maria De Benedetto
  2. Maria De Benedetto
    1. 2.2.1 A Psychological Attitude No access Maria De Benedetto
    2. 2.2.2 An Evidence-Based Sentiment No access Maria De Benedetto
    3. 2.2.3 Confidence and Trust: Decisional Aspects No access Maria De Benedetto
  3. 2.3 Confidence as Output of Controls No access Maria De Benedetto
3. 3. Confidence as Institutional Determinant No access Maria De Benedetto
4. 4. Confidence as a Pillar of Effective Legislation and Regulation No access Maria De Benedetto
5. Maria De Benedetto
  1. 5.1 Reasons No access Maria De Benedetto
  2. 5.2 Responsibilities No access Maria De Benedetto
6. 6. Restoring Confidence in Legislation in Times of Pandemic No access Maria De Benedetto
1. José Esteve Pardo
  1. 1. Introduction No access José Esteve Pardo
  2. 2. Historical Frame No access José Esteve Pardo
  3. 3. Social Transformation and New Political Knowledge from the New Sciences No access José Esteve Pardo
  4. 4. Criticism of Parliamentarianism and its Theorists No access José Esteve Pardo
  5. 5. The Influence of Anti-Parliamentary Doctrines on Current Legislation and Institutions No access José Esteve Pardo
2. Ulrich Karpen
  1. 1. Governance in Crisis? No access Ulrich Karpen
  2. 2. Confidence in the Rule of Law State No access Ulrich Karpen
  3. 3. Better Legislation No access Ulrich Karpen
  4. 4. Better Implementation No access Ulrich Karpen
  5. 5. In Need of Better Government! No access Ulrich Karpen
3. Helen Xanthaki
  1. Helen Xanthaki
    1. 1.1 STEP 1: Identifying the Users of EU Legislation No access Helen Xanthaki
    2. 1.2 STEP 2: Setting the Pitch of EU Legislative Texts No access Helen Xanthaki
    3. 1.3 STEP 3: A Better Structure for EU Legislation No access Helen Xanthaki
  2. 2. But Why Change? Trust and Loyalty No access Helen Xanthaki
  3. 3. Conclusions No access Helen Xanthaki
1. Claudio M. Radaelli, Gaia Taffoni
  1. 1. The argument No access Claudio M. Radaelli, Gaia Taffoni
  2. 2. Scene One: Regulatory Impact Assessment No access Claudio M. Radaelli, Gaia Taffoni
  3. 3. Scene Two: Judicial Review No access Claudio M. Radaelli, Gaia Taffoni
  4. 4. The Encounter Between RIA and Judicial Review No access Claudio M. Radaelli, Gaia Taffoni
  5. 5. Judicial Deference No access Claudio M. Radaelli, Gaia Taffoni
  6. 6. Conclusions No access Claudio M. Radaelli, Gaia Taffoni
2. Nicoletta Rangone
  1. 1. Effective Consultation and Public Trust No access Nicoletta Rangone
  2. Nicoletta Rangone
    1. 2.1 Accessibility of the Process No access Nicoletta Rangone
    2. 2.2 Early Stage Consultation No access Nicoletta Rangone
    3. 2.3 Accessibility of the Documents No access Nicoletta Rangone
    4. 2.4 Reasonable Time to Intervene No access Nicoletta Rangone
    5. 2.5 Feedback and Justification of Final Rules No access Nicoletta Rangone
    6. 2.6 Consultation to Secure Compliance No access Nicoletta Rangone
  3. 3. How to Balance Increased Participation and Collection of Valuable Contribution Only? No access Nicoletta Rangone
  4. 4. Conclusions No access Nicoletta Rangone
3. Elena Griglio
  1. 1. Introduction. The Crisis of Confidence in Legislation as a Crisis of Democratic Legitimacy No access Elena Griglio
  2. 2. Better regulation’s Contribution to Increase the Confidence in Legislation No access Elena Griglio
  3. 3. Parliaments as Strategic Actors for Fulfilling the Proposed Vision of Better Regulation No access Elena Griglio
  4. 4. Parliaments’ Engagement in Better Regulation Processes No access Elena Griglio
  5. 5. Better Regulation in Parliament: Legislation or Oversight? No access Elena Griglio
  6. 6. Conclusions. Strengthening the Confidence Dimension for Increasing the Confidence in Legislation No access Elena Griglio
4. Egle Basyte Ferrari, Eckehard Rosenbaum, Giulia Listorti, Nicole Ostlaender
  1. 1. Introduction No access Egle Basyte Ferrari, Eckehard Rosenbaum, Giulia Listorti, Nicole Ostlaender
  2. 2. Better regulation, transparency and trust No access Egle Basyte Ferrari, Eckehard Rosenbaum, Giulia Listorti, Nicole Ostlaender
  3. Egle Basyte Ferrari, Eckehard Rosenbaum, Giulia Listorti, Nicole Ostlaender
    1. Method No access Egle Basyte Ferrari, Eckehard Rosenbaum, Giulia Listorti, Nicole Ostlaender
    2. Findings No access Egle Basyte Ferrari, Eckehard Rosenbaum, Giulia Listorti, Nicole Ostlaender
    3. Evaluations No access Egle Basyte Ferrari, Eckehard Rosenbaum, Giulia Listorti, Nicole Ostlaender
    4. Impact assessments No access Egle Basyte Ferrari, Eckehard Rosenbaum, Giulia Listorti, Nicole Ostlaender
  4. 4. Discussion and concluding remarks No access Egle Basyte Ferrari, Eckehard Rosenbaum, Giulia Listorti, Nicole Ostlaender
1. Nicola Lupo
  1. 1. Introduction: Parliament and Confidence in Legislation between Tradition and Change No access Nicola Lupo
  2. 2. The Italian Parliamentary Form of Government No access Nicola Lupo
  3. 3. The “Normative Role” of the Government No access Nicola Lupo
  4. 4. Delegated Legislation in Two Steps: Delegation Laws and Legislative Decrees No access Nicola Lupo
  5. 5. Urgency Legislation and its Abuses: Decree-Laws and Conversion Laws No access Nicola Lupo
  6. 6. The Powers of the Government in the Legislative Process: the Question of Confidence on Maxi-Amendments No access Nicola Lupo
  7. 7. The Case-Law of the Constitutional Court: Trying the Avoid the More Evident Flaws in Law-Making No access Nicola Lupo
  8. 8. Constant Trends and Pitfalls in Italian Law-Making and the Success of Populist Movements No access Nicola Lupo
  9. 9. Conclusion. Which Legislative Role for Parliaments? No access Nicola Lupo
2. Giovanni Rizzoni
  1. 1. Introduction No access Giovanni Rizzoni
  2. 2. Efforts to Enhance the Quality of Legislation No access Giovanni Rizzoni
  3. 3. Transparency of the Legislative Procedure as a Factor of Trust No access Giovanni Rizzoni
  4. 4. Confidence and Fairness of the Legislative Procedure No access Giovanni Rizzoni
  5. 5. Trust and Self-recognition of Citizens in Parliamentary Decisions No access Giovanni Rizzoni
  6. 6. Conclusions No access Giovanni Rizzoni
3. Patricia Popelier
  1. 1. Introduction: Linking Political and Legal Notions No access Patricia Popelier
  2. 2. Trust in Parliament: an overview No access Patricia Popelier
  3. 3. Trust and legitimate expectations No access Patricia Popelier
  4. Patricia Popelier
    1. Step 1 No access Patricia Popelier
    2. Step 2 No access Patricia Popelier
    3. Step 3 No access Patricia Popelier
  5. 5. Conclusion No access Patricia Popelier
4. Manuela Guggeis
  1. 1. Introduction No access Manuela Guggeis
  2. Manuela Guggeis
    1. 2.1 The Interinstitutional Agreement on Better Law-Making (2003) and its Follow-Up No access Manuela Guggeis
    2. 2.2 From Better to Smart Regulation. No access Manuela Guggeis
    3. 2.3 EU Regulatory Fitness No access Manuela Guggeis
    4. 2.4 Better Regulation for Better Results: an EU Agenda No access Manuela Guggeis
    5. 2.5 The New Interinstitutional Agreement on Better Law-Making (2016) No access Manuela Guggeis
    6. 2.6 Transparency No access Manuela Guggeis
    7. 2.7 Quality of Drafting No access Manuela Guggeis
    8. 2.8 Way Forward No access Manuela Guggeis
  3. Manuela Guggeis
    1. 3.1 The National Parliaments and the Regulatory Framework Introduced by the Lisbon Treaty No access Manuela Guggeis
    2. 3.2 The Informal Political Dialogue No access Manuela Guggeis
    3. 3.3 Protocol no. 2 to the Lisbon Treaty: the Early Warning Mechanism No access Manuela Guggeis
    4. 3.4 The COSAC No access Manuela Guggeis
    5. 3.5 Way Forward No access Manuela Guggeis
  4. 4. Final Remarks No access Manuela Guggeis
1. Wim Voermans
  1. 1. Man-Made Law No access Wim Voermans
  2. 2. Why Do We Obey? No access Wim Voermans
  3. Wim Voermans
    1. The Leap over Dunbar's number No access Wim Voermans
  4. Wim Voermans
    1. Increasing scale No access Wim Voermans
  5. 5. How Does Trust Work? No access Wim Voermans
  6. 6. Imagined World of the Law No access Wim Voermans
  7. 7. Trust as the X-Factor No access Wim Voermans
2. Florentin Blanc
  1. 1. Introduction No access Florentin Blanc
  2. Florentin Blanc
    1. 2.1. What Links between “Regulation”, “Regulatory Delivery”, and the “Trust” Issue? No access Florentin Blanc
    2. Florentin Blanc
      1. 2.3 Regulatory “Incomprehensibility”, Impossibility of “Optimal” Rules and Need for Discretion No access Florentin Blanc
      2. 2.4 Discretion, “Corruption”, Trust and Distrust No access Florentin Blanc
  3. Florentin Blanc
    1. 3.1. Perceptions, Expectations, and Distrust No access Florentin Blanc
    2. 3.2. Effective Regulatory Delivery No access Florentin Blanc
  4. 4. Conclusion No access Florentin Blanc
1. Cary Coglianese
  1. 1. Introduction No access Cary Coglianese
  2. 2. The Crisis in Legal Confidence No access Cary Coglianese
  3. 3. Scapegoating Law No access Cary Coglianese
  4. 4. Brexit and Legal Scapegoating No access Cary Coglianese
  5. 5. Brazil, Bolsonaro, and Bullying the Law No access Cary Coglianese
  6. 6. Donald Trump’s Assault on U.S. Law No access Cary Coglianese
  7. 7. The Political Economy of Legal Scapegoating No access Cary Coglianese
  8. 8. How Laws Are Like Migrants No access Cary Coglianese
  9. 9. The Consequences of Legal Scapegoating No access Cary Coglianese
  10. 10. Implications for Action and Research No access Cary Coglianese
  11. 11. Conclusion No access Cary Coglianese