Cover of book: Between Climate Cases and Legitimacy
Book Titles Open Access Full access

Between Climate Cases and Legitimacy

A Discourse Theoretical Perspective on Judicial Climate Decisions
Authors:
Publisher:
 2025

Summary

The author considers how, and whether, discourse theory can legitimise judicial decisions in climate cases. Taking into account the role of courts in a democratic society, the implications of distinguishing between discourses of application and discourses of justification, and the proper elaboration of the system of rights, the book evaluates the possibility of justifying climate decisions using discourse theory. Building upon Kuhli and Günther’s (2011) adaptation of the discourse of norm application to a discourse of norm identification, as well as their criteria for legitimate judicial law-making, it elaborates upon this justification. Ultimately, the theory is applied to climate-related decisions "in Neubauer v. Germany and Verein KlimaSeniorinnen Schweiz v. Switzerland."

Keywords



Bibliographic data

Copyright year
2025
ISBN-Print
978-3-68900-466-8
ISBN-Online
978-3-68900-467-5
Publisher
Tectum, Baden-Baden
Series
Young Academics: European Legal Theory
Volume
4
Language
English
Pages
90
Product type
Book Titles

Table of contents

ChapterPages
  1. Download chapter (PDF)
    1. Foreword
  2. 1 IntroductionPages 11 - 20 Download chapter (PDF)
  3. Download chapter (PDF)
      1. 2.1.1 General Remarks
      2. 2.1.2 The Co-Originality Thesis and the System of Rights
      1. 2.2.1 The Constitutional State [Rechtsstaat]
      2. 2.2.2 The Role of the Judiciary
      3. 2.2.3 Constitutional Adjudication
  4. Download chapter (PDF)
    1. 3.1 Climate Rights for the Protection of Private and Public Autonomy
      1. 3.2.1 Constitutionalisation by the Citizens and Legitimate Judicial Law-Making
      2. 3.2.2 Shifting to Norm Identification
  5. Download chapter (PDF)
    1. 4.1 Neubauer of the German Federal Constitutional Court
    2. 4.2 KlimaSeniorinnen of the European Court of Human Rights
  6. 5 ConclusionPages 81 - 84 Download chapter (PDF)
  7. ReferencesPages 85 - 88 Download chapter (PDF)
  8. AcknowledgementsPages 89 - 90 Download chapter (PDF)

Similar publications

from the series "Young Academics: European Legal Theory"
Cover of book: An Empirical Analysis of Legal Reasoning in Czechia
Book Titles Full access
Tomáš Koref
An Empirical Analysis of Legal Reasoning in Czechia
Cover of book: Spectres of Kant
Book Titles Full access
Thodoris Kokkaliaris
Spectres of Kant
Cover of book: … but Life gives Spirit?
Book Titles Full access
Marius Mikkel Kjølstad
… but Life gives Spirit?
Cover of book: In Defence of the Concept of Law
Book Titles Full access
Cameron Moss
In Defence of the Concept of Law
Cover of book: Balancing Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendments
Book Titles Full access
Gürkan Çapar
Balancing Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendments