Plato’s Parmenides

Prof. Dr. Luc Brisson; Dr. Arnaud Macé; Dr. Olivier Renaut

doi:10.5771/9783985720217

Keywords

Search publication

Bibliographic data

Publication year: 2022
Publication date: 14.07.2022
ISBN-Print: 978-3-98572-020-0
ISBN-Online: 978-3-98572-021-7
Publisher: Academia, Baden-Baden
Series: International Plato Studies
Volume: 41
Language: German
Pages: 568
Product type: Edited Book

Titelei/Inhaltsverzeichnis No access Pages 1 - 4
Introduction No access Pages 5 - 14
1. François Renaud
  1. 1. Historicité No access François Renaud
  2. 2. Tradition orale No access François Renaud
  3. 3. Bon usage de l’écriture No access François Renaud
2. Nikos G. Charalabopoulos
  1. 1. Three oddities and a puzzle No access Nikos G. Charalabopoulos
  2. 2. (Inter)Textuality No access Nikos G. Charalabopoulos
  3. Nikos G. Charalabopoulos
    1. 1. The Magnificent Seven No access Nikos G. Charalabopoulos
    2. 2. The (not so) Magnificent Seven (ish) No access Nikos G. Charalabopoulos
  4. 4. The Parmenides pendulum No access Nikos G. Charalabopoulos
3. Lidia Palumbo
  1. 1. Introduzione No access Lidia Palumbo
  2. 2. Il Sofista di Elea No access Lidia Palumbo
  3. 3. Gli Eleati come philotheamones No access Lidia Palumbo
  4. 4. Il Palamede eleatico e l’Eleatismo apotrettico No access Lidia Palumbo
  5. 5. Sui personaggi No access Lidia Palumbo
1. Parmenide e il cavallo di Ibico: l’immagine dell’eros senile per la dialettica (Prm. 136e-137c) No access Pages 43 - 50 Mario Regali
2. Julia Pfefferkorn
  1. 1. Parmenides und die Hypothese des nicht-seienden Einen No access Julia Pfefferkorn
  2. 2. Der Einleitungsteil: eine fruchtlose Vermittlung, der Wettkampf und Pferde No access Julia Pfefferkorn
  3. 3. Der historische und der literarische Parmenides No access Julia Pfefferkorn
  4. 4. Wenn das Eine nicht ist No access Julia Pfefferkorn
  5. 5. Das Erbe der Philosophie des Parmenides No access Julia Pfefferkorn
3. André Luiz Braga da Silva
  1. 1. What does the hypothesis mean? No access André Luiz Braga da Silva
  2. 2. Could this hypothesis be an allusion to an existing doctrine? No access André Luiz Braga da Silva
  3. 3. Is the refutation of the hypothesis sound? The understanding of its argument in the light of an Aristotelian notion No access André Luiz Braga da Silva
  4. 4. Final considerations No access André Luiz Braga da Silva
4. D. Gregory MacIsaac
  1. Introduction No access D. Gregory MacIsaac
  2. D. Gregory MacIsaac
    1. Step One: Whole and Part No access D. Gregory MacIsaac
    2. Step Two: Forms and Participants No access D. Gregory MacIsaac
    3. Step Three: The One and the Others No access D. Gregory MacIsaac
  3. Conclusion No access D. Gregory MacIsaac
5. La dottrina eleatica dell’Uno-tutto nel primo λόγος di Zenone No access Pages 75 - 82 Francesco Ferro
6. Sandra Peterson
  1. Introduction No access Sandra Peterson
  2. A disagreement about Zeno’s target that this essay need not settle No access Sandra Peterson
  3. Nehamas’s reasons against crediting Socrates with a severe objection No access Sandra Peterson
  4. Conclusion No access Sandra Peterson
7. Filippo Forcignanò
  1. 1. The proem of the Parmenides: why Clazomenae? No access Filippo Forcignanò
  2. 2. An Anaxagorean eponymy? No access Filippo Forcignanò
  3. 3. μοῖραν μετέχειν, ἐφ’ ἑαυτοῦ and χωρισθῆναι: beyond Anaxagorean participation No access Filippo Forcignanò
  4. 4. Conclusion No access Filippo Forcignanò
8. Mathilde Brémond
  1. 1. Gorgias in Plato’s Parmenides No access Mathilde Brémond
  2. 2. Gorgias’ Method and Its Platonic Use No access Mathilde Brémond
  3. 3. Antilogic and the Parmenides’ Method No access Mathilde Brémond
  4. 4. Conclusion No access Mathilde Brémond
9. Il Parmenide di Platone fra il Περὶ τοῦ μὴ ὄντος di Gorgia e il Περὶ τοῦ ὄντος di Protagora: l’ombra dei sofisti nella γυμνασία No access Pages 115 - 122 Michele Corradi
10. Ivana Costa
  1. Gorgias en la primera parte del Parménides No access Ivana Costa
  2. El eleatismo de Gorgias y el Parménides No access Ivana Costa
  3. Gorgias en la segunda parte del Parménides No access Ivana Costa
  4. La fuerza de la dialéctica y la fuerza de las hipótesis No access Ivana Costa
11. Claudia Mársico
  1. I No access Claudia Mársico
  2. II No access Claudia Mársico
  3. III No access Claudia Mársico
  4. IV No access Claudia Mársico
1. Mary-Louise Gill
  1. The Exercise on Oneness No access Mary-Louise Gill
  2. Repetition with Variation No access Mary-Louise Gill
  3. Mary-Louise Gill
    1. Heraclitus and Parmenides in the Theaetetus No access Mary-Louise Gill
    2. Battle of Gods and Giants No access Mary-Louise Gill
    3. Aporia about Being No access Mary-Louise Gill
2. Annie Larivée
  1. L’insistance sur le thème de l’âge No access Annie Larivée
  2. Annie Larivée
    1. Prescription d’exercice ‘gymnique’ No access Annie Larivée
    2. La démonstration gymnique No access Annie Larivée
  3. Comment Socrate devient Socrate dans le Phédon No access Annie Larivée
3. Parmenides’ hypothesis behind Plato’s Parmenides: ‘all the things are collectively called ἓν ὄν’ (Sph. 242d6) No access Pages 173 - 182 Sergio Di Girolamo
4. On common forms and dialectical inquiry in Plato’ Parmenides No access Pages 183 - 192 Jens Kristian Larsen
5. Georgia Mouroutsou
  1. A. Introducing Plato’s Dialectic No access Georgia Mouroutsou
  2. B1. First Argument: 142c7-143a3 No access Georgia Mouroutsou
  3. B2. Second Argument 143a4-144e7 No access Georgia Mouroutsou
  4. C. Diagnosing the Parmenides Dialectic (of the two arguments) with the aid of the Sophist No access Georgia Mouroutsou
  5. D. Conclusion No access Georgia Mouroutsou
6. Alessio Santoro
  1. Introduction No access Alessio Santoro
  2. Parmenides’ exercise No access Alessio Santoro
  3. Zenonian (or Parmenidean?) training No access Alessio Santoro
  4. Aristotelian dialectic No access Alessio Santoro
  5. Conclusions No access Alessio Santoro
1. Noburu Notomi
  1. 1. Dilemma of transcendence in the Parmenides No access Noburu Notomi
  2. 2. Similarity introduced No access Noburu Notomi
  3. 3. Zeno’s paradox No access Noburu Notomi
  4. 4. Regress of similarities No access Noburu Notomi
  5. 5. Similarity defined No access Noburu Notomi
  6. 6. Homonymy and synonymy No access Noburu Notomi
  7. 7. Conclusion No access Noburu Notomi
2. Sind die Ideen wirklich unteilbar? Zur zweifachen Natur der platonischen Formen (Prm. 131a-e) No access Pages 221 - 228 Antonino Spinelli
3. Irina Protopopova
  1. Indivisible day or divisible sail? No access Irina Protopopova
  2. Types of eide: qualitative and assembling No access Irina Protopopova
  3. What is virtue — gold or a face? No access Irina Protopopova
  4. Soul and polis: both divisible and indivisible? No access Irina Protopopova
  5. The Sophist: An ‘intelligible atom’ No access Irina Protopopova
  6. Back to the Parmenides No access Irina Protopopova
  7. The Typology of eide No access Irina Protopopova
4. Vittorio Ricci
  1. Introduzione No access Vittorio Ricci
  2. 1. L’aporia del grande No access Vittorio Ricci
  3. 2. L’argomento dell’impartecipabilità per rassomiglianza No access Vittorio Ricci
  4. Conclusione No access Vittorio Ricci
5. Separation Anxieties. Parmenides 133a-135c No access Pages 245 - 252 Amber D. Carpenter
6. Beatriz Bossi
  1. I No access Beatriz Bossi
  2. Beatriz Bossi
    1. III No access Beatriz Bossi
    2. IV No access Beatriz Bossi
7. José Antonio Giménez
  1. 1. El argumento No access José Antonio Giménez
  2. 2. Los sentidos de δύναμις No access José Antonio Giménez
  3. 3. Los dioses y las Formas No access José Antonio Giménez
8. Irmgard Männlein-Robert
  1. I. Der ferne Gott No access Irmgard Männlein-Robert
  2. II. Der Zweifler und die Distanz No access Irmgard Männlein-Robert
  3. III. Literarische Strategien der Distanzierung No access Irmgard Männlein-Robert
9. Carolina Araújo
  1. Carolina Araújo
    1. II No access Carolina Araújo
    2. III No access Carolina Araújo
10. Kezhou Liu
  1. Kezhou Liu
    1. II. Which thesis of separation does Plato hold? No access Kezhou Liu
    2. III. Plato’s response to the problem of separation in Part II No access Kezhou Liu
1. Maurizio Migliori
  1. Some preliminary remarks No access Maurizio Migliori
  2. The one and the other/the others No access Maurizio Migliori
  3. The Whole and the Parts No access Maurizio Migliori
  4. The One as Principle No access Maurizio Migliori
  5. Final thoughts No access Maurizio Migliori
2. Eric Sanday
  1. The Subject and Number of Hypotheses in Plato’s Parmenides No access Eric Sanday
  2. The Subject of the Hypotheses No access Eric Sanday
  3. The Number of Hypotheses No access Eric Sanday
  4. Conclusion No access Eric Sanday
3. Béatrice Lienemann
  1. 1. Einleitung No access Béatrice Lienemann
  2. 2. Meinwalds Interpretationsansatz No access Béatrice Lienemann
  3. Béatrice Lienemann
    1. 3.1. PTA-Prädikationen No access Béatrice Lienemann
    2. 3.2. PH-Prädikationen No access Béatrice Lienemann
  4. Béatrice Lienemann
    1. 4.1. Essentielle und notwendige Eigenschaften No access Béatrice Lienemann
    2. 4.3. Essentielle Eigenschaften und PH-Prädikationen im Phaidon No access Béatrice Lienemann
    3. 4.4. Notwendige Eigenschaften im Sophistes: die Passage der megista genê No access Béatrice Lienemann
  5. 5. Schluss No access Béatrice Lienemann
4. La deuxième partie du Parménide : identité et altérité de l’intelligible ? No access Pages 331 - 338 Luca Pitteloud
5. Dialectic and Forms in Prm. 137c-144e No access Pages 339 - 346 Dougal Blyth
6. Mateo Duque
  1. Being in Time: is it really the only kind of Being there is? No access Mateo Duque
  2. Mateo Duque
    1. 1) Reconsidering the final paradoxical claims of the first hypothesis No access Mateo Duque
    2. 2) The link between the tenseless Forms and the atopos nature of ‘the Instant’ [τὸ ἐξαίφνης] No access Mateo Duque
    3. 3) How to Interpret the First Hypothesis and the Parmenides in general No access Mateo Duque
7. Il numero come prototipo di pluralità unificata (Prm.147a3-6) No access Pages 355 - 360 Carmen Di Lorenzo
8. The One and Time: Parmenides 151e-153a No access Pages 361 - 370 Richard Parry
9. Aleksei A. Pleshkov
  1. 1. Introduction No access Aleksei A. Pleshkov
  2. 2. Common interpretations of the notion ‘eternity’ No access Aleksei A. Pleshkov
  3. 3. Neo-eternalism No access Aleksei A. Pleshkov
  4. 4. Fundamental Ontology of the Present No access Aleksei A. Pleshkov
  5. 5. Conclusion No access Aleksei A. Pleshkov
10. Francisco J. Gonzalez
  1. The prevailing alternative interpretations of ‘the third’ No access Francisco J. Gonzalez
  2. Problems with all three interpretations No access Francisco J. Gonzalez
  3. A fourth interpretation: ‘the third’ as mediating deductions one and two No access Francisco J. Gonzalez
  4. ‘The third’ as mediating all of the opposed deductions: the hinge on which all of the deductions turn No access Francisco J. Gonzalez
  5. Conclusion No access Francisco J. Gonzalez
11. Samuel Meister
  1. 1. The One and the Others No access Samuel Meister
  2. 2. Gunk No access Samuel Meister
  3. 3. The Aporetic Reading No access Samuel Meister
12. Claudia Luchetti
  1. 1) 142a-144e No access Claudia Luchetti
  2. 2) 155e-157b No access Claudia Luchetti
  3. 3) 157b-159b No access Claudia Luchetti
  4. Conclusione No access Claudia Luchetti
13. Roberto Granieri
  1. 0. Introduzione No access Roberto Granieri
  2. 1. Riferimento No access Roberto Granieri
  3. 2. Essere e partecipazione No access Roberto Granieri
  4. 3. Conclusioni No access Roberto Granieri
14. Francesco Aronadio
  1. IpVI No access Francesco Aronadio
  2. IpV No access Francesco Aronadio
  3. Parallelo con Sph. 237-239 No access Francesco Aronadio
15. Lorenzo Giovannetti
  1. Lorenzo Giovannetti
    1. 164b5-c6 No access Lorenzo Giovannetti
    2. 164c7-d8 No access Lorenzo Giovannetti
    3. 164d9-165b4 No access Lorenzo Giovannetti
    4. 165b5-e1 No access Lorenzo Giovannetti
  2. Lorenzo Giovannetti
    1. Mutual differentiation and the concept of appearance No access Lorenzo Giovannetti
    2. Particular sensible things No access Lorenzo Giovannetti
    3. The infinite divisibility of the empirical and the intelligible unity No access Lorenzo Giovannetti
    4. The Absence of the One as what the others differ from No access Lorenzo Giovannetti
    5. Consequences for the others with respect to what? No access Lorenzo Giovannetti
16. Jan Szaif
  1. The guiding hypothesis and the arguments of Deduction VII No access Jan Szaif
  2. Suggestions for identifying the objects discussed in Deduction VII No access Jan Szaif
  3. Conclusion No access Jan Szaif
17. I-Kai Jeng
  1. 1. A Brief Critique No access I-Kai Jeng
  2. I-Kai Jeng
    1. Deduction V No access I-Kai Jeng
    2. Deduction VI No access I-Kai Jeng
    3. Deduction VII No access I-Kai Jeng
    4. Deduction VIII No access I-Kai Jeng
1. Federico M. Petrucci
  1. 1. Premessa No access Federico M. Petrucci
  2. 2. Partire dalla fine: le conseguenze teologiche della “difficoltà” (134c6-e8) No access Federico M. Petrucci
  3. 3. Intermezzo: cenni sulla dottrina stoica delle categorie No access Federico M. Petrucci
  4. 4. Autoidentità e determinazione No access Federico M. Petrucci
  5. 5. Relazione e disposizione No access Federico M. Petrucci
  6. 7. Conclusioni (provvisorie) No access Federico M. Petrucci
2. Apuleian Evidence regarding Pre-Plotinian Interpretation of the Parmenides No access Pages 483 - 490 Harold Tarrant
3. Plotinus and Parmenides No access Pages 491 - 500 Lloyd P. Gerson
4. Forms as paradigms in Plato’s Parmenides 132c-d. Proclus’ response to Aristotle and Alexander of Aphrodisias’ attacks on the Forms considered as patterns No access Pages 501 - 508 Melina G. Mouzala
5. Anna Motta
  1. 1. No access Anna Motta
  2. 2. No access Anna Motta
  3. 3. No access Anna Motta
  4. 4. No access Anna Motta
  5. 5. No access Anna Motta
6. Simplicio, in Cael. 556, 3-560, 10, a margine di Platone, Prm. 135b8-c1. Prolegomeni a una genealogia del parallelismo onto-epistemologico No access Pages 517 - 526 Ivan Adriano Licciardi
References No access Pages 527 - 568