Framing Peace

Dr. Till Blume

doi:10.5771/9783845232652

Summary

UN Friedensmissionen tragen in Konfliktregionen zu Sicherheit bei. Dabei müssen diese mit lokalen Akteuren interagieren. Im Mittelpunkt stehen dabei die Wahrnehmung von Sicherheit und die Kommunikation über Sicherheit. Wie Sicherheit und Öffentlichkeitsarbeit im Konfliktgebiet zusammenhängen, und wie effektive Öffentlichkeitsarbeit für UN Friedensmissionen überlebenswichtig sein kann, zeigt „Framing Peace“ anhand von drei Fallstudien zu den UN-Missionen in Bosnien-Herzegowina, dem Kosovo und Liberia. Schwerpunkt liegt dabei auf den Polizeikomponenten der drei UN-Friedensmissionen. Die Arbeit deckt den Zeitraum der Entwicklung von UN Friedensmissionen zwischen 1996 bis 2006 ab.

Search publication

Bibliographic data

Copyright year: 2011
ISBN-Print: 978-3-8329-6873-1
ISBN-Online: 978-3-8452-3265-2
Publisher: Nomos, Baden-Baden
Series: Nomos Universitätsschriften - Politik
Volume: 179
Language: English
Pages: 376
Product type: Book Titles

Titelei/Inhaltsverzeichnis No access Pages 2 - 16
Illustrations No access Pages 17 - 18
Tables No access Pages 19 - 22
List of Acronyms No access Pages 23 - 26
1. Organizational Framing and Strategic Peacebuilding No access Pages 27 - 34
2. 1. Framing and Peace Operations No access
3. 1. UN Peace Operations as Organizations No access Pages 42 - 44
  2. Public Information Offices (PIO) in Peace Operations No access Pages 44 - 47
  3. Environments of UN Peace Operations No access Pages 47 - 52
1. Framing and Organizational Framing No access Pages 53 - 54
2. 1. What are Frames? No access Pages 54 - 56
  2. What is Framing? No access Pages 56 - 58
  3. Organizational Framing: Strategy and Design No access Pages 58 - 61
3. 1. The Context: Peace Operations in the Field No access Pages 61 - 62
  2. 1. The Kind of Situation No access
    2. Context Credibility No access
    3. Capacities: Security Policies No access
  3. Frames as Dependent Variables – Prototypical Frames in Peace Operations No access Pages 68 - 72
  4. Hypotheses No access Pages 72 - 74
  5. 1. UN Peace Operations as Complex Organizations: Bounded Rationality and ‘Satisficing’ No access
    2. Leadership as Key Factor No access
    3. Influencing Frame Selection: Bureaucratic Efficiency No access
4. Summing Up: Hypotheses and Independent Variables for Frame Selection in UN Peace Operations No access Pages 77 - 78
1. Methods and Peace Operations No access Pages 79 - 80
2. Herding Mice: Process Tracing and Qualitative Methods No access Pages 80 - 81
3. 1. Inference in Process Tracing No access Pages 81 - 84
  2. Generalization in Process Tracing No access Pages 84 - 85
4. 1. Four Steps No access Pages 85 - 87
  2. 1. Specifying Independent Variables No access
    2. Specifying Dependent Variables: Frame Selection No access
    3. Two Preliminary Case Studies No access
  3. Second Step: Tracing Frames in the Empirical Material No access Pages 91 - 92
  4. 1. Comparing Prototypical and Empirical Frames No access
    2. Merging Frames No access
  5. Fourth Step: Structured and Focused Comparison of Hypotheses and Frame Selection No access Pages 94 - 97
5. Data No access Pages 97 - 100
6. Case Selection No access Pages 100 - 102
1. UNMIBH’s Mandate: Monitoring and Reforming Police in BiH No access Pages 103 - 107
2. Setup of Police Forces in Bosnia-Herzegovina No access Pages 107 - 108
3. The Role of Media in Bosnia-Herzegovina No access Pages 108 - 110
4. UNMIBH’s Media Policy No access Pages 110 - 111
5. Critical Periods for UNMIBH No access Pages 111 - 112
6. 1. 1. Kind of Period No access
    2. Context Credibility No access
    3. Security Policies No access
    4. Bureaucratic Efficiency No access
    5. Summary of Independent Variables No access
  2. Framing a Difficult Heritage: UNMIBH’s First Year No access Pages 117 - 121
  3. Assessment of Framing and Hypotheses No access Pages 121 - 124
7. 1. 1. Kind of Period No access
    2. Context Credibility No access
    3. Security Policies No access
    4. Bureaucratic Efficiency No access
    5. Summary of Independent Variables No access
  2. Framing New Competences: The Bonn Powers No access Pages 132 - 136
  3. Assessment of Framing and Hypotheses No access Pages 136 - 138
8. Excursus: UNMIBH and Political Developments 1998-2001 No access Pages 138 - 139
9. 1. 1. Kind of Period No access
    2. Context Credibility No access
    3. 1. MIP Core Program 1: Police Reform and Vetting No access
      2. MIP Core Program 4: Institution building and Inter-Police Force Cooperation No access
    4. Bureaucratic Efficiency No access
    5. Summary of Independent Variables No access
  2. 1. Short summary for 2001 No access
    2. UNMIBH’s Last Year – 2002 in Frames No access
  3. Assessment of Framing and Hypotheses No access Pages 156 - 161
10. 1. Structured and Focused Comparison of Independent Variables No access Pages 161 - 163
  2. Frames Over Time No access Pages 163 - 163
  3. Assessing Hypotheses for UNMIBH No access Pages 163 - 168
1. 1. The Mandate: Resolution 1244 No access Pages 169 - 173
  2. UNMIK Police in 1999 No access Pages 173 - 175
  3. Media in Kosovo and Public Information No access Pages 175 - 177
2. UNMIK between 2001 and 2005 No access Pages 177 - 179
3. 1. 1. Kind of Period No access
    2. Context Credibility No access
    3. Security Policies No access
    4. Bureaucratic Efficiency No access
    5. Summary of Independent Variables No access
  2. Framing the Elections 2001 No access Pages 186 - 191
  3. Assessing Framing and Hypotheses No access Pages 191 - 194
4. 1. 1. Kind of Period No access
    2. Context Credibility No access
    3. Security Policies No access
    4. Bureaucratic Efficiency No access
    5. Summary No access
  2. Framing Standards in Kosovo No access Pages 201 - 204
  3. Assessing Framing and Hypotheses No access Pages 204 - 209
5. 1. 1. Kind of Period No access
    2. Context Credibility No access
    3. Security Policies No access
    4. Bureaucratic Efficiency No access
    5. Summary No access
  2. Framing Failure: The March Riots 2004 No access Pages 215 - 221
  3. Assessing Frames during the March Riots 2004 No access Pages 221 - 224
6. 1. 1. Kind of Period No access
    2. Context Credibility No access
    3. Security Policies No access
    4. Bureaucratic Efficiency No access
    5. Summary No access
  2. Framing towards Ownership? No access Pages 230 - 235
  3. Assessing Frames 2004/2005 No access Pages 235 - 238
7. 1. Independent Variables No access Pages 238 - 240
  2. Frames Over Time No access Pages 240 - 242
  3. Assessing Hypotheses for UNMIK 2001-2005 No access Pages 242 - 244
8. Epilogue: UNOSEK and the Status Proposal 2007-2008 No access Pages 244 - 248
1. 1. Security Institutions in Liberia No access Pages 249 - 253
  2. Media Institutions in Liberia No access Pages 253 - 254
  3. The Accra Peace Agreement 2003 No access Pages 254 - 256
  4. 1. UNMIL Police No access
    2. UNMIL Public Information Office No access
2. Critical Periods during UNMIL’s tenure No access Pages 259 - 261
3. 1. 1. Kind of Period No access
    2. Context Credibility No access
    3. Security Policies No access
    4. Bureaucratic Efficiency No access
    5. Summary No access
  2. From Deployment to DDRR: Press Briefings and Frames No access Pages 269 - 274
  3. Assessing Framing and Hypotheses No access Pages 274 - 278
4. 1. 1. Kind of Period No access
    2. Context Credibility No access
    3. Security Policies No access
    4. Bureaucratic Efficiency No access
    5. Summary No access
  2. Framing Towards Transition: Press Briefings and Frames in 2004 No access Pages 284 - 289
  3. Assessing Framing and Hypotheses No access Pages 289 - 293
5. 1. 1. Kind of Period No access
    2. Context Credibility: Scoring for Elections No access
    3. Security Policies No access
    4. Bureaucratic Efficiency No access
    5. Summary of Independent Variables No access
  2. Framing the Elections 2006: Press Briefings and Frames No access Pages 299 - 301
  3. Assessment of Frames and Hypotheses No access Pages 301 - 305
6. 1. 1. Kind of Period No access
    2. Context Credibility No access
    3. Security Policies No access
    4. Bureaucratic Efficiency No access
    5. Summary No access
  2. Towards Consolidation: Frame Selection in 2006/2007 No access Pages 312 - 321
  3. Assessing Framing and Hypotheses No access Pages 321 - 324
7. 1. Structured and Focused Comparison of Independent Variables No access Pages 324 - 325
  2. Frames Over Time No access Pages 325 - 328
  3. Assessing Hypotheses Across the Periods No access Pages 328 - 329
  4. Framing Peace and Security in Liberia No access Pages 329 - 330
1. 1. Liberia: Rebuilding a Failed State No access Pages 331 - 334
  2. Kosovo No access Pages 334 - 335
  3. Bosnia-Herzegovina No access Pages 335 - 335
2. 1. The Two Main Hypotheses No access Pages 335 - 338
  2. Kind of Period No access Pages 338 - 339
  3. Context Credibility No access Pages 339 - 339
  4. Security Policies No access Pages 339 - 339
  5. Summing Up: Testing Hypotheses of Framing Peace No access Pages 339 - 340
3. 1. From ‘Security First’ to Development: The Different Phases of Peace Operations No access Pages 340 - 342
  2. Personality in Peacekeeping: The Role of Leadership No access Pages 342 - 343
  3. Mission Design No access Pages 343 - 344
4. 1. Mixing Methods: Frame Analysis and Process Tracing No access Pages 344 - 345
  2. Theoretical Considerations: Framing Theory, Frame Selection and Organizational Framing No access Pages 345 - 347
5. Implications for Peacekeeping Research: Sketching an Agenda for further Research No access Pages 347 - 376