Pointing, Rainbows, and the Archaeology of Mind

Table of contents

Bibliographic information

Cover of Volume: Anthropos Volume 116 (2021), Edition 1
No access

Internationale Zeitschrift für Völker- und Sprachenkunde

Volume 116 (2021), Edition 1

Authors:
, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Publisher
Nomos, Baden-Baden
Publication year
2021
ISSN-Online
2942-3139
ISSN-Print
0257-9774

Chapter information

No access

Volume 116 (2021), Edition 1

Pointing, Rainbows, and the Archaeology of Mind

Buy in shop
Authors:
ISSN-Print
0257-9774
ISSN-Online
2942-3139
Preview:

For over a century anthropologists and folklorists have sporadically recorded a belief that one should not point at a rainbow, lest the offending finger become permanently bent, rot, be supernaturally severed, fall off, etc. In each case the belief was reported for a particular geographical region without apparent awareness of its presence elsewhere, and in no case was an explanation for this curious idea proposed. This paper documents what is called the “Rainbow Taboo” as a global phenomenon, found among peoples of quite varied cultural backgrounds, and it argues that the universality of the belief is a product of the interaction of two independent cognitive elements: an apparently innate sense that the rainbow is associated with the “other world,” and, secondly, a similar sense that pointing with the index finger is aggressive, and should not be used either in normal human interactions or more particularly against the supernatural.

Bibliography

  1. Adriani, Nicolaus, and Albert C. Kruyt Open Google Scholar
  2. 1950–1951 De Bare’e sprekende Toradja’s van Midden Celebes. Vol 3. Amsterdam: Noord-Hollandsche Uitg. Mij. [2nd Rev. Ed., 1st Ed. 1912–1914] Open Google Scholar
  3. Alinei, Mario Open Google Scholar
  4. 1983 Arc-en-ciel. In: M. Alinei (ed.), Atlas Linguarum Europae. Vol. 1. Facs. 1; pp. 47–80. Assen: van Gorcum. Open Google Scholar
  5. 1985 Evidence for Totemism in European Dialects. International Journal of American Linguistics 51/4: 331–334. Open Google Scholar
  6. Anonymous Open Google Scholar
  7. 1963 Religious Rites of the Iban. In: A. Richards (ed.), The Sea Dyaks and Other Races of Sarawak. Contributions to the Sarawak Gazette between 1888 and 1930; pp. 175–221. Kuching: Borneo Literature Bureau. Open Google Scholar
  8. Bader, Hermann Open Google Scholar
  9. 1971 Der Regenbogen in der Auffassung der Florinesen. Anthropos 66: 947–955. Open Google Scholar
  10. Barnes, Robert H. Open Google Scholar
  11. 1974 Kédang. A Study of the Collective Thought of an Eastern Indonesian People. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Open Google Scholar
  12. Blust, Robert Open Google Scholar
  13. 1981 Linguistic Evidence for Some Early Austronesian Taboos. American Anthropologist 83/2: 285–319. Open Google Scholar
  14. 2000 The Origin of Dragons. Anthropos 95: 519–536. Open Google Scholar
  15. n.d. The Dragon and the Rainbow. Man’s Oldest Story. [Manuscript, 274 pp.] Open Google Scholar
  16. Butterworth, George E. Open Google Scholar
  17. 1997 Starting Point. Natural History 106/4: 14–16. Open Google Scholar
  18. 1998 What Is Special about Pointing in Babies? In: F. Simion and G. E. Butterworth (eds.), The Development of Sensory, Motor, and Cognitive Capacities in Early Infancy. From Perception to Cognition; pp. 171–190. Hove: Psychology Press. Open Google Scholar
  19. Calbris, Geneviève Open Google Scholar
  20. 1990 Semiotics of French Gestures. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. Open Google Scholar
  21. Campbell, Lyle Open Google Scholar
  22. 2013 Historical Linguistics. An Introduction. Cambridge: MIT Press. [3rd Ed.] Open Google Scholar
  23. Carrasco, Pedro Open Google Scholar
  24. 1960 Pagan Rituals and Beliefs among the Chontal Indians of Oaxaca, Mexico. Anth-ropological Records 20/3: 87–117. Open Google Scholar
  25. Chen, Chien-wu Open Google Scholar
  26. 1991 Tai-wan yuen-zhu-min de mu-yu chuan-shuo [Myths of the Taiwan Aborigines]. Taipei: Tai-yuan. Open Google Scholar
  27. Christy, Craig Open Google Scholar
  28. 1983 Uniformitarianism in Linguistics. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Open Google Scholar
  29. Comrie, Bernard Open Google Scholar
  30. 1989 Language Universals and Linguistic Typology. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. [2nd Ed.] Open Google Scholar
  31. Cooperrider, Kensy, James Slotta, and Rafael Núñez Open Google Scholar
  32. 2018 The Preference for Pointing with the Hand Is Not Universal. Cognitive Science 42/4: 1375–1390. Open Google Scholar
  33. Croft, William Open Google Scholar
  34. 2003 Typology and Universals. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [2nd Ed.] Open Google Scholar
  35. Demetrio, Francisco R. Open Google Scholar
  36. 1991 Encyclopedia of Philippine Folk Beliefs and Customs. Vol. 1. Cagayan de Oro: Xavier University. [Enl. and Rev. Ed.; 1st Ed. 1970] Open Google Scholar
  37. Dorsey, J. Owen Open Google Scholar
  38. 1889 Teton Folk-Lore Notes. Journal of American Folk-Lore 2/5: 133–139. Open Google Scholar
  39. Drucker, Philip Open Google Scholar
  40. 1937 Culture Element Distributions. V: Southern California. Anthropological Records 1/1: 1–52. Open Google Scholar
  41. Egerod, Søren Open Google Scholar
  42. 1965 Verb Inflexion in Atayal. Lingua 15: 251–282. Open Google Scholar
  43. Elkin, A. P. Open Google Scholar
  44. 1930–1931 The Rainbow-Serpent Myth in North-West Australia. Oceania 1: 349–52. Open Google Scholar
  45. Enfield, Nick J., and Stephen C. Levinson (eds.) Open Google Scholar
  46. 2006 Roots of Human Sociality. Culture, Cognition, and Interaction. Oxford: Berg. Open Google Scholar
  47. Erdland, August Open Google Scholar
  48. 1914 Die Marshall-Insulaner. Leben und Sitte, Sinn und Religion eines Südsee-Volkes. Münster: Aschendorff. Open Google Scholar
  49. Essene, Frank Open Google Scholar
  50. 1942 Culture Element Distributions. XXI: Round Valley. Anthropological Records 8/1: 1–97. Open Google Scholar
  51. Evans, Ivor H. N. Open Google Scholar
  52. 1923 Studies in Religion, Folk-Lore, and Custom in British North Borneo and the Ma-lay Peninsula. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Open Google Scholar
  53. Fagan, Brian M. Open Google Scholar
  54. 2010 Cro-Magnon. How the Ice Age Gave Birth to the First Modern Humans. New York: Bloomsbury Press. Open Google Scholar
  55. Feilberg, Henning F. Open Google Scholar
  56. 1886–1914 Bidrag til en Ordbog over jyske Almuesmal. 4 Vols. Kjöbenhavn: Thieles Bogtrykkeri. Open Google Scholar
  57. Forsberg, Vivian, and Alice Lindquist Open Google Scholar
  58. 1955 Tagabili Vocabulary. Manila: Summer Institute of Linguistics, Bureau of Public Schools, Institute of National Language. Open Google Scholar
  59. Foster, George M. Open Google Scholar
  60. 1941 A Summary of Yuki Culture. Anthropological Records 5/3: 154–241. Open Google Scholar
  61. Gaidoz, Henri Open Google Scholar
  62. 1884–85 L’arc-en-ciel. Mélusine. Recueil de mythologie, littérature populaire, traditi-ons et usages 4: 9–18. Open Google Scholar
  63. Greenberg, Joseph H. (ed.) Open Google Scholar
  64. 1978 Universals of Human Language. 4 Vols. Stanford: Stanford University Press. Open Google Scholar
  65. Grimm, Jakob Open Google Scholar
  66. 1844 Deutsche Mythologie. Göttingen: Dieterich. [2nd Ed.] Open Google Scholar
  67. Hadfield, Emma Open Google Scholar
  68. 1920 Among the Natives of the Loyalty Group. London: Macmillan. Open Google Scholar
  69. Haviland, John B. Open Google Scholar
  70. 1993 Anchoring, Iconicity, and Orientation in Guugu Yimithirr Pointing Gestures. Journal of Linguistic Anthropology 3/1: 3–45. Open Google Scholar
  71. 1997 How to Point in Zinacantán. (Paper Presented at the Max-Planck Workshop on “Pointing Gestures.” Oud-Turnhout, Belgium, June 1997.) Open Google Scholar
  72. Hewes, Gordon W. Open Google Scholar
  73. 1981 Pointing and Language. In: T. Myers, J. Laver, and J. Anderson (eds.), The Cog-nitive Representation of Speech; pp. 263–269. Amsterdam: North Holland. Open Google Scholar
  74. Hilger, M. Inez Open Google Scholar
  75. 1952 Arapaho Child Life and Its Cultural Background. Washington: Smithsonian In-stitution. Open Google Scholar
  76. Hole, Christina Open Google Scholar
  77. 1995 Rainbow. In: R. Cavendish (ed.), Man, Myth, and Magic. The Illustrated Encyc-lopaedia of Mythology, Religion, and the Unknown. Vol. 15: Phal – Rasp; pp. 2153–2155. New York: Marshall Cavendish. Open Google Scholar
  78. Holt, Catharine Open Google Scholar
  79. 1946 Shasta Ethnography. Anthropological Records 3/4: 299–349. Open Google Scholar
  80. Howitt, Alfred W. Open Google Scholar
  81. 1996 The Native Tribes of South-East Australia. Canberra: Aboriginal Studies Press. [1st Ed. 1904] Open Google Scholar
  82. Ivens, Walter G. Open Google Scholar
  83. 1972 Melanesians of the South-East Solomon Islands. New York: Benjamin Blom. [1st Ed. 1927] Open Google Scholar
  84. Jakobson, Roman Open Google Scholar
  85. 1960 Why Mama and Papa? In: B. Kaplan and S. Wapner (eds.), Perspectives in Psy-chological Theory. Essays in Honor of Heinz Werner; pp. 124–134. New York: Interna-tional Universities Press. Open Google Scholar
  86. James, Wendy Open Google Scholar
  87. 1988 The Listening Ebony. Moral Knowledge, Religion, and Power among the Uduk of Sudan. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Open Google Scholar
  88. Karlgren, Bernhard Open Google Scholar
  89. 1950 The Book of Odes. Chinese Text, Transcription, and Translation. Stockholm: Museum of Far Eastern Antiquities. Open Google Scholar
  90. Kendon, Adam, and Laura Versante Open Google Scholar
  91. 2003 Pointing by Hand in “Neapolitan.” In: S. Kita (ed.); pp. 109–137. Open Google Scholar
  92. Kita, Sotaro (ed.) Open Google Scholar
  93. 2003 Pointing. Where Language, Culture, and Cognition Meet. London: Lawrence Er-lbaum Associates. Open Google Scholar
  94. Labov, William Open Google Scholar
  95. 1994 Principles of Linguistic Change. Vol. 1: Internal Factors. Oxford: Blackwell. Open Google Scholar
  96. Laughlin, Robert M. Open Google Scholar
  97. 1975 The Great Tzotzil Dictionary of San Lorenzo Zinacantán. Washington: Smithso-nian Institution. Open Google Scholar
  98. Leach, Maria, and Jerome Fried (eds.) Open Google Scholar
  99. 1972 Funk and Wagnall’s Standard Dictionary of Folklore, Mythology, and Legend. New York: Funk & Wagnalls. Open Google Scholar
  100. Lévi-Strauss, Claude Open Google Scholar
  101. 1970 Introduction to a Science of Mythology. Vol. 1: The Raw and the Cooked (Transl. by John and Doreen Weightman.) London: Jonathan Cape. [French Orig. 1964] Open Google Scholar
  102. Liszkowski, Ulf, Penny Brown, Tara Callaghan, Akira Takada, and Conny de Vos Open Google Scholar
  103. 2012 A Prelinguistic Gestural Universal of Human Communication. Cognitive Science 36/4: 698–713. Open Google Scholar
  104. Lock, A., A. Young, V. Service, and P. Chandler Open Google Scholar
  105. 1990 Some Observations on the Origins of the Pointing Gesture. In: V. Volterra and C. J. Erting (eds.), From Gesture to Language in Hearing and Deaf Children; pp. 42–55. Berlin: Springer. Open Google Scholar
  106. Lowie, Robert Open Google Scholar
  107. 1924 Primitive Religion. New York: Boni and Liveright. Open Google Scholar
  108. Maan, G. Open Google Scholar
  109. 1940 Boelisch-Nederlandsche woordenlijst. Met Nederlandsch-Boelisch register. Bandoeng: A. G. Nix. Open Google Scholar
  110. Marshall, Harry I. Open Google Scholar
  111. 1922 The Karen People of Burma. A Study in Anthropology and Ethnology. Colum-bus: Ohio State University. Open Google Scholar
  112. Métraux, Alfred Open Google Scholar
  113. 1946 Myths of the Toba and Pilagá Indians of the Gran Chaco. Philadelphia: American Folklore Society. Open Google Scholar
  114. Mills, James P. Open Google Scholar
  115. 1926 The Ao Nagas. London: Macmillan. Open Google Scholar
  116. Mooney, James Open Google Scholar
  117. 1970 Myths of the Cherokee. New York: Johnson Reprint Corporation. [1st Ed. 1900] Open Google Scholar
  118. Mountford, Charles P. Open Google Scholar
  119. 1958 The Tiwi. Their Art, Myth, and Ceremony. London: Phoenix House. Open Google Scholar
  120. Müller, Cornelia Open Google Scholar
  121. 1997 Zur Unhöflichkeit von Zeigegesten. (Paper Presented at the Max-Planck Work-shop on “Pointing Gestures.” Oud-Turnhout, Belgium, June 1997.) Open Google Scholar
  122. Nordenskiöld, Erland Open Google Scholar
  123. 1938 An Historical and Ethnological Survey of the Cuna Indians. Göteborg: Göte-borgs Museum, Etnografiska Avdelningen. Open Google Scholar
  124. Norenzayan, Ara, Scott Atran, Jason Faulkner, and Mark Schaller Open Google Scholar
  125. 2006 Memory and Mystery. The Cultural Selection of Minimally Counterintuitive Nar-ratives. Cognitive Science 30/3: 531–553. Open Google Scholar
  126. Parry, Neville E. Open Google Scholar
  127. 1932 The Lakhers. (With an Introduction and Supplementary Notes by J. H. Hutton.) London: Macmillan. Open Google Scholar
  128. Pedraza, Jesus S. Open Google Scholar
  129. 1978 The Otomí. Vol. 1. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press. Open Google Scholar
  130. Pinker, Steven Open Google Scholar
  131. 1994 The Language Instinct. How the Mind Creates Language. New York: William Morrow. Open Google Scholar
  132. Radcliffe-Brown, Alfred R. Open Google Scholar
  133. 1930–1931 The Rainbow-Serpent Myth in South-East Australia. Oceania 1/3: 342–347. Open Google Scholar
  134. Radford, Edwin, and Mona Augusta Radford Open Google Scholar
  135. 1975 Encyclopedia of Superstitions. London: Hutchinson. Open Google Scholar
  136. Rehg, Kenneth L., and Damien G. Sohl Open Google Scholar
  137. 1979 Ponapean-English Dictionary. Honolulu: The University Press of Hawaii. Open Google Scholar
  138. Renfrew, Colin Open Google Scholar
  139. 1982 Towards an Archaeology of Mind. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Open Google Scholar
  140. Rolland, Eugène Open Google Scholar
  141. 1888–89 L’arc-en-ciel. Partie XXXIV. Mélusine. Recueil de mythologie, littérature populaire, traditions et usages 4: 561. Open Google Scholar
  142. Sherzer, Joel Open Google Scholar
  143. 1973 Verbal and Nonverbal Deixis. The Pointed Lip Gesture among the San Blas Cu-na. Language and Society 2: 117–131. Open Google Scholar
  144. Smith, Marian W. Open Google Scholar
  145. 1940 The Puyallup-Nisqually. New York: Columbia University Press. Open Google Scholar
  146. Smith, Neil Open Google Scholar
  147. 1999 Chomsky. Ideas and Ideals. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Open Google Scholar
  148. Steward, Julian H. Open Google Scholar
  149. 1941 Culture Element Distributions. XIII: Nevada Shoshone. Anthropological Records 4/2: 209–360. Open Google Scholar
  150. Teit, James A. Open Google Scholar
  151. 1900 The Thompson Indians of British Columbia. In: Memoirs of the American Muse-um of Natural History. Vol. 2: Anthropology. Part 1: The Jesup North Pacific Expediti-on; pp. 163–392. New York: American Museum of Natural History. Open Google Scholar
  152. Thompson, Stith Open Google Scholar
  153. 1955 Motif-Index of Folk-Literature. A Classification of Narrative Elements in Folktales, Bal-lads, Myths, Fables, Mediaeval Romances, Exempla, Fabliaux. Vol. 1: A–G. Bloomington: Indi-ana University Press. [Orig. 1932] Open Google Scholar
  154. Vanoverbergh, Morice Open Google Scholar
  155. 1972 Isneg-English Vocabulary. Honolulu: The University Press of Hawaii. Open Google Scholar
  156. Werner, Alice Open Google Scholar
  157. 1933 Myths and Legends of the Bantu. London: George G. Harrap. Open Google Scholar
  158. Wheeler-Voegelin, Erminie Open Google Scholar
  159. 1942 Culture Element Distributions, XX: Northeast California. Anthropological Records 7/2: 47–252. Open Google Scholar
  160. Wuttke, A. Open Google Scholar
  161. 1869 Der deutsche Volksaberglaube der Gegenwart. Berlin: Wiegand & Grieben. [2nd Ed.] Open Google Scholar

Citation

Download RIS Download BibTex
No access
You do not have access to this content.

Share via email

Media